Panel selection for strata and commercial façades

Solid aluminium vs ACP cladding: what building owners should compare

By Sydney Contracting Engineers (SCE Corp)

Solid aluminium cladding and aluminium composite panels can look similar on a finished building, but their construction is different. A solid aluminium panel has a solid metal body. An aluminium composite panel, commonly called ACP, has aluminium skins bonded around a core. That distinction matters when strata committees, building owners and asset managers compare replacement façade options.

Start by identifying the exact panel and its proposed use. Then compare the complete wall design, fixing arrangement, finish, maintenance plan and installed scope. Neither the word “solid” nor a composite-panel classification establishes that an entire façade is suitable for a particular building.

Belmont apartment façade during recladding works, with site fencing and access equipment
The Belmont façade during recladding delivery. SCE delivered the construct-only remediation scope to the project’s issued regulated designs.

Solid aluminium versus ACP: the practical differences

ACP is a family of products, not a single specification. Core composition differs between products and can materially affect their characteristics. NSW Government describes the construction of composite cladding and the importance of its core. Product records and appropriate investigation are more reliable than identifying a panel from a photograph.

What owners should compare in façade proposals
Decision Solid aluminium panel Aluminium composite panel
Panel construction A solid aluminium body, with the specified finish and fabricated form. Aluminium skins around a bonded core; the exact core and product must be identified.
Product evidence Match the panel, thickness, finish and installation arrangement to the design evidence. Match skins, core, finish and complete product identity to the evidence and intended use.
Façade appearance Review panel size, folds, joints, support and acceptable visual tolerances. Review panel size, routing or folding method, joints, support and visual tolerances.
Existing supports Confirm the selected system’s loads and fixing requirements before retaining existing framing. Confirm the selected system’s loads and fixing requirements before retaining existing framing.
Commercial comparison Price the full installed system, interfaces and fabrication requirements. Price the full installed system, interfaces and product-specific fabrication requirements.

Are aluminium composite panels banned in NSW?

The NSW ban concerns specified uses of ACP with a core containing more than 30% polyethylene by mass. Its application depends on the building and use, and the published notice includes exceptions. It is not a blanket statement that every composite panel is banned or that every existing installation must be removed.

Use the current NSW aluminium composite panel ban notice with the appointed building professionals. For the broader topic, our cladding types, bans and regulations guide explains the questions to raise. A product described as A2 still requires project-specific assessment; the label alone is not approval for every application.

Why replacing ACP with solid aluminium is a system decision

A replacement panel can change fabrication, joints, supports and installation details. SCE assesses the existing members and building connections against the new system, including their dimensions, age, corrosion and damage. A fixing face that is too narrow, or support spacing that does not match the new panels, is a different issue from inadequate structural capacity.

Where engineering confirms that existing vertical supports can remain, designed horizontal rails may create suitable fixing positions for the new panel layout. This can reduce additional direct anchoring into the building, while adding its own framing weight and façade depth. Those changes, the connections and the moisture-control interfaces must be resolved together. Our concealed support and fixing guide explains why a new rail layout cannot substitute for repairing weakened members.

Ask for coordinated details at windows, doors, parapets, balconies, corners and penetrations. These junctions affect water management and buildability. If water ingress or substrate deterioration is present, define the investigation and repair scope alongside the panel replacement rather than assuming the new facing will solve the underlying defect.

SCE delivers solid aluminium panel cladding from engineering and design through procurement, fabrication, installation and handover, bringing the relevant specialists and suppliers together for the building. Our A2 composite cladding pathway sets out the product and project questions for that separate option. The selected solution must follow the project’s approved design and allocated professional responsibilities.

Compare appearance using a sample assembly

Owners often compare a colour sample before the panel layout has been resolved. Ask to review panel dimensions, joint spacing, corner treatment and how the proposed façade aligns with windows and existing architectural features. Consider how the finish appears in direct sunlight and from normal viewing positions.

A sample assembly can make the decision more concrete. Include the proposed panel, visible fixings or concealed-fixing arrangement, trims and one representative junction. Agree the inspection criteria before manufacturing the main order. Fairview’s overview of aluminium product forms is useful background, but manufacturer literature does not replace the project specification.

Which option costs less over the life of the building?

There is no reliable universal price winner. The comparable figure is a quotation for the same elevations, performance requirements and construction scope. Include removal, disposal, investigations, design inputs, support work, fabrication, access, temporary protection, installation, inspection and handover.

For an occupied apartment or commercial building, ask what each option means for programme and disruption. Different panel layouts or fixing methods may change the work sequence. Access mobilisation, balcony restrictions, delivery space and weather protection can be commercially significant even where the panel supply prices are close.

Also compare cleaning requirements, coating care, warranty conditions and how a damaged panel would be replaced. Confirm whether spare material or a retained finish reference would help future repairs. Our façade access planning guide helps owners frame these discussions before tender prices are finalised.

What the Belmont recladding project demonstrates

At SCE’s Belmont recladding project, SCE acted as the construct-only remediation contractor under Project Remediate. The scope included removal of nominated ACP and related combustible materials and delivery of the replacement façade to issued regulated designs. Practical completion was achieved on 9 May 2025.

The existing bonded composite sheets were replaced with folded solid aluminium panels. The selected system required different supporting construction and side details. Cassette folds used part of each sheet, so SCE coordinated the finished panel sizes and joints with the required façade pattern. Corroded components exposed during the work were addressed as part of the construction scope.

The coastal location also informed the specified coating and finish. Belmont shows why a material change needs a complete installation plan: a similar façade appearance does not mean the old substrate, support arrangement or flat-sheet dimensions can simply be reused. SCE resolved those practical interfaces within the project’s issued design and consultant-review process.

Six questions to put into a material-options brief

  1. What exactly is proposed? Record manufacturer, product, panel construction, thickness, finish and supporting documents.
  2. Why is it suitable here? Ask the appointed design team to identify the project requirements and evidence supporting the chosen system.
  3. What is being retained? Identify existing supports and interfaces that need inspection or design confirmation.
  4. What does the price include? Align access, removal, repairs, temporary protection, installation and close-out scope.
  5. How will appearance be approved? Agree samples, panel layout, junction details and inspection criteria before manufacture.
  6. What will the owner receive? Specify product records, agreed installation evidence, warranties and maintenance information at handover.

Bring the available drawings, product records and façade reports into the discussion early. SCE’s cladding replacement team can review the construction scope, access and delivery requirements for your building. A clear brief gives the project team a sound basis for comparing suitable systems and obtaining meaningful prices.

Explore our cladding material and compliance questions for the wider design, installation and ownership decisions behind a panel selection.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between solid aluminium and ACP?

A solid aluminium panel has a solid metal body. An aluminium composite panel has aluminium skins bonded around a core. ACP core composition varies, so the exact product and proposed system must be identified.

Are all aluminium composite panels banned in NSW?

No. The NSW ban applies to specified uses of ACP with more than 30% polyethylene by mass in its core, subject to the published notice and exceptions. The appointed project professionals should assess the exact product, building and proposed use.

Can existing ACP simply be replaced with solid aluminium?

The replacement needs a coordinated design and construction scope. Confirm supports, fixings, movement, joints, flashings, water-management interfaces and other affected components before assuming a direct substitution is suitable. At Belmont, changing from bonded composite sheets to folded solid aluminium required changes to the supporting construction, panel set-out and side details.

Does an A2 classification approve a panel for every building?

No. A classification is part of the product evidence. The exact system, intended use, applicable project requirements and required approvals still need assessment.

What information helps SCE review a cladding replacement?

Provide the building address, façade photographs, available drawings and reports, known product records, approximate height and area, access constraints, occupancy requirements and intended programme.